Most carrier estimates are produced in estimating software and follow a similar layout. Once you know where to look, you can spot the gaps that matter.
The summary page
Start at the end. The summary shows replacement cost value (RCV), depreciation, actual cash value (ACV), the deductible and the net claim. Check that the deductible matches your declarations page — especially if you have a percentage wind/hail deductible.
Areas and quantities
The estimate is organized by area: roof, elevations, rooms. Each area lists measurements. Compare roof squares, wall areas and linear feet with your own measurements or an aerial report. Small measurement errors multiply across every line in that area.
Line items
Each line has a description, quantity, unit price and total. Watch for:
- Repair versus replace — “R&R” means remove and replace; “repair” or “detach and reset” mean something cheaper.
- Missing tear-off or disposal.
- Underlayment, ice barrier, drip edge and starter on roofs.
- Paint, texture and trim after drywall repairs.
- Steep and high charges on roofs.
Depreciation
Depreciation is usually shown per line or per area. Check the age and life used, and whether non-material items like labor are depreciated. Our RCV / ACV holdback calculator helps model the numbers.
Overhead and profit
If your repair needs several trades coordinated by a general contractor, look for overhead and profit. Its absence on a multi-trade job is one of the most common gaps.
What to do with what you find
List the differences, attach photos and your contractor’s estimate, and send a supplement request. If the gap is large and the carrier won’t move, a professional carrier estimate review is the logical next step before appraisal.




