How appraisal works
What is insurance appraisal?
A process in most property policies for resolving disagreements about the amount of a covered loss. Each side names an appraiser, the appraisers choose an umpire, and an award signed by two of the three sets the amount.
Who can demand appraisal?
Usually either party — you or the insurer — can demand it in writing once you disagree on the amount of loss. Check your policy for any conditions that must be met first.
Is appraisal the same as arbitration?
Not exactly. Appraisal is narrower: it focuses on valuing the loss and is usually less formal than arbitration, with no hearings in the courtroom sense.
Can I be my own appraiser?
Most policies require a competent and impartial appraiser, which effectively rules out the policyholder. Hiring an experienced independent appraiser is the norm.
Does the insurer’s appraiser work for the insurer?
The insurer selects and pays its appraiser, just as you select and pay yours. Both are expected to be impartial under most policy wording.
Costs and timing
How much does an appraiser cost?
Fee arrangements vary — flat fees, hourly rates or a percentage of the increase. Whatever the basis, get it in writing before work starts. Umpire fees are usually split.
How long does appraisal take?
Many residential files resolve in two to three months after both appraisers are named. Large commercial, wildfire or contents-heavy claims can take longer.
Is there a deadline to demand appraisal?
Some policies set one, and the policy’s suit-limitation clause still runs. Read your policy and calendar the dates with our timeline builder.
Is the award paid right away?
Payment terms depend on the policy. The insurer pays the award less the deductible and prior payments; recoverable depreciation usually follows once repairs are done.
When is a gap too small for appraisal?
When fees would consume most of the increase. As a rough guide, gaps under about 10% or a few thousand dollars are often better handled with a documented supplement request.
Hail, wildfire and other perils
Can appraisal decide whether my roof should be replaced?
Appraisal values the cost to repair or replace covered damage, so repair-versus-replace disputes are often part of it. Coverage questions, such as cosmetic exclusions, may not be.
Does appraisal work for wildfire total losses?
Yes, for disputes about the cost to rebuild, debris removal or contents values within your limits. It can’t increase the limits themselves.
What about smoke damage to a house that didn’t burn?
Smoke and ash cleaning or replacement disputes are a common appraisal topic, provided the insurer has accepted that a covered loss occurred.
Can I use appraisal for a frozen-pipe claim?
If coverage is accepted, yes. Freezing and vacancy exclusions are coverage questions that may need to be resolved first.
Does appraisal apply to my car?
Some auto policies have appraisal clauses, but our work focuses on homes and commercial buildings.
Colorado specifics
Who regulates insurers in Colorado?
The Colorado Division of Insurance, part of the Department of Regulatory Agencies (DORA). It licenses insurers and adjusters and accepts consumer complaints.
What is the Colorado FAIR Plan?
A last-resort property insurance program created by the legislature in 2023 for owners who can’t find coverage in the regular market, particularly in high-wildfire-risk areas. It began offering policies in 2025.
Does Colorado have a bad-faith law?
Yes. Colorado statutes address unreasonable delay or denial of covered benefits, alongside common-law bad-faith claims. Those are legal matters for an attorney, not an appraisal panel.
Can my roofer pay my deductible?
No. Colorado law prohibits roofing contractors from paying, waiving or rebating a homeowner’s insurance deductible.
Who appoints an umpire if the appraisers can’t agree?
Under typical policy language, a court of record in the county where the property sits — in Colorado, usually the district court.

