Most hail disputes along the Front Range aren’t about whether it hailed. They’re about how much damage the storm did, whether the roof can be repaired and whether the damage came from this storm or an earlier one. Good documentation answers those questions before they become arguments.
1. Pin down the storm date
Write down the date and time the storm hit. Save local news coverage, weather service storm reports and neighbors’ accounts. If more than one storm struck during the season, note each date. Policies apply deductibles per occurrence, and the date of loss affects which storm is responsible.
2. Photograph stones while you can
Photos of hailstones next to a coin, ruler or tape measure — taken during or right after the storm — are strong evidence of size. A few stones in a freezer bag in the freezer don’t hurt either.
3. Start with soft metals
Gutters, downspouts, roof vents, flashing and window wraps dent easily and record hail size and direction. Photograph them up close with a scale reference, and from a distance to show which sides of the house were hit.
4. Document every slope
On the roof, inspectors often mark test squares (10 by 10 feet) on each slope and count hits. Even if you don’t go on the roof yourself, ask your contractor for slope-by-slope photos with chalk marks and a scale. Fractured mats, granule loss and exposed fiberglass matter more than surface scuffs.
5. Don’t forget the elevations
Siding, screens, garage doors, paint, decks, fences and outdoor equipment on the sides facing the storm are part of the claim. They’re also the items most often left off a first estimate.
6. Gather the roof’s history
If your roof was replaced after an earlier storm, keep the invoice, permit and photos. That record answers “prior damage” arguments quickly. Note the shingle manufacturer and line if you know them — discontinued products drive repair-versus-replace disputes.
7. Compare apples to apples
When the carrier’s estimate arrives, line it up against your contractor’s estimate by item: squares, waste, underlayment, ice barrier, drip edge, vents, gutters and elevations. Our roof pitch & squares calculator helps check the measurements.
The bottom line
Panels value what can be shown. Documentation gathered in the first weeks after a storm is often the difference between a patch and a roof.




