How the estimator works
Appraisal panels rarely award either side’s full number. They work through the estimates line by line and usually land somewhere in between. The slider lets you test that: choose a landing point within the disputed amount, and the tool projects an award and subtracts what appraisal would cost you.
- Amount in dispute is your estimate minus the carrier’s.
- Projected award is the carrier’s number plus your chosen share of the gap.
- Your costs are your appraiser’s fee — flat, a percentage of the increase, or an hourly rate times hours — plus half the umpire’s fee if you expect one.
- Break-even landing point is the share of the gap the award must reach just to cover your costs.
Reading the three scenarios
The scenario table runs the same math at 25%, 50% and 75% of the gap. If your net is negative even at 50%, a documented supplement request or a professional carrier estimate review is usually the better first step. If it’s solidly positive at 25%, appraisal is worth a serious conversation.
Illustrative example
With the default figures — a $21,800 carrier estimate and a $38,400 contractor estimate — the gap is $16,600. At a 55% landing point the projected award is about $30,930. These numbers are illustrative only, not a result from any real claim.
What the estimator can’t tell you
It can’t judge whether your estimate is defensible. An inflated estimate makes the gap look large and the award land low. Before relying on any number, make sure each line item is supported by photos, measurements and local pricing.
Questions about this tool
Where do awards usually land?
There’s no reliable average. Results depend on documentation, pricing support and how many items are truly disputed. Use the scenarios to see a range rather than a prediction.
Why include an hourly option?
Some appraisers bill hourly on complex commercial or contents-heavy files. Enter your rate and an estimate of hours to compare it with a flat or percentage fee.
Does a bigger gap always mean appraisal is worth it?
Not if the gap comes from coverage questions — exclusions, wear and tear or late notice. Appraisal values covered damage; it doesn’t decide coverage.




