What the appraisal clause does
Most Colorado homeowners and commercial property policies include a short condition titled “Appraisal.” The usual wording says that if you and the insurer fail to agree on the amount of loss, either side may demand appraisal in writing. Each side then chooses a competent, impartial appraiser; the two appraisers select an umpire; and a written agreement signed by any two of the three sets the amount of loss.
That last part is what gives appraisal weight. It isn’t mediation and it isn’t a suggestion. Once two signatures are on the award, the amount of loss is generally decided — which is why the person you appoint matters.
What we do as your appraiser
- Read the demand and the policy first. Some forms give each side a set number of days to name an appraiser; some require a sworn proof of loss before appraisal. We confirm the steps and dates before anything else happens.
- Scope the loss independently. We inspect, measure and photograph the property ourselves instead of editing the carrier’s estimate, so every line in our number can be explained.
- Price it for your market. Repair costs in Summit County, Colorado Springs and Grand Junction differ. Our estimate uses current local pricing and treats code items and overhead and profit the way your policy reads.
- Work the differences with the other appraiser. Most panels narrow the dispute to a short list of items through site meetings and line-by-line comparison.
- Help select a qualified umpire and, if needed, present the remaining items with photos, measurements and pricing support.
- Review the award form so replacement cost, actual cash value and depreciation are spelled out before anyone signs.
Worth knowing
Appraisal sets the amount of a covered loss. It generally doesn’t decide coverage, and it doesn’t award damages for bad faith or attorney’s fees. If your insurer denied the claim outright, a Colorado attorney may be the right first call.
When representation makes sense
Appraisal works best when coverage is accepted and the disagreement is about scope or price: whether a hail-damaged roof can be repaired or must be replaced, whether discontinued siding can be matched, how much smoke cleaning a wildfire-exposed house really needs. It is less useful when the dispute is really about an exclusion, wear and tear or late notice.
How we stay credible
We tell you plainly what we think a panel is likely to accept. An appraiser who inflates a number to win a client loses credibility with the umpire, and credibility is what moves awards. Our estimates are built to hold up under scrutiny rather than to impress on first read.
Common questions
Can I choose any appraiser I want?
You choose your own appraiser, but most policies require that person to be competent and impartial or disinterested. An appraiser with a financial stake in the repair contract can create problems for the award.
Can the insurer refuse a proper appraisal demand?
If the policy has an appraisal clause and the dispute is about the amount of loss, the insurer generally participates once a proper written demand is made. Coverage disputes are a different matter and may fall outside appraisal.
How long does appraisal take?
Straightforward residential files often resolve within two to three months after both appraisers are named. Large commercial, contents-heavy or wildfire files, or panels that need an umpire, can take longer.




