Why the first check feels short
On most replacement-cost policies, the insurer first pays the actual cash value — replacement cost minus depreciation — less your deductible. The depreciation is “held back” and paid once repairs are done and documented. On an older roof, that holdback can be a large share of the claim.
How the math works
- Each item’s depreciation is its age divided by its expected life, times its replacement cost, up to the cap you choose.
- The optional O&P box adds 10% overhead and 10% profit to replacement cost, a common convention when a general contractor coordinates several trades.
- The next check is ACV minus the deductible and any payments you’ve already received.
- If your roof is settled at ACV only — some policies use a roof payment schedule or ACV endorsement — tick the box and the holdback becomes zero.
Colorado roofs and depreciation
Intense high-altitude sun ages asphalt shingles, and many Front Range roofs have been replaced after earlier hail. Depreciation disputes often turn on the roof’s real age, the expected life used, and whether the policy has a roof schedule. Check your declarations page and endorsements, then compare the carrier’s figures with the estimate.
Deadlines matter
Most policies set a time limit to complete repairs and claim recoverable depreciation. Put it on your calendar with the claim timeline builder.
Questions about this tool
Is labor depreciated in Colorado?
Practice varies by insurer and estimate, and the policy language matters. If labor is depreciated on your estimate, ask the adjuster which policy provision they are relying on.
What life should I use for a shingle roof?
Use the expected life the carrier used if it’s on the estimate, then test a different figure. Material, manufacturer, ventilation and exposure all affect real service life.
Does appraisal set depreciation?
An appraisal award often states both replacement cost and actual cash value, which is why disputed depreciation can be part of an appraisal.




