Why hail claims get disputed
The Front Range and the plains east of it sit in what forecasters call Hail Alley. Many neighborhoods have been hit more than once in a decade, and that history creates arguments: was this damage from the latest storm or an earlier one? Can the roof be repaired, or are the shingles too brittle and discontinued? Is a dented metal vent “cosmetic”?
What a complete hail scope covers
- Roof covering — slope-by-slope test squares, bruising and fractured mat, granule loss and exposed fiberglass, documented with chalk and scale.
- Soft metals — gutters, downspouts, vents, flashing and fascia wraps. Dent size and spacing help establish hail size and direction.
- Elevations — siding, window screens and wraps, garage doors, paint, decks and fencing on the sides facing the storm.
- Roof system items — underlayment, ice-and-water barrier at eaves and valleys, drip edge, ridge vent, starter and steep or high-roof charges.
- Interior — ceiling stains and insulation where hail-damaged roofing let water in.
Common Colorado hail disputes
- Spot repairs written on laminated shingles that are no longer manufactured in the existing color or profile.
- Roofs settled at actual cash value or on a roof payment schedule — read the declarations and endorsements carefully.
- Cosmetic damage exclusions on metal roofing or siding.
- Percentage wind/hail deductibles that swallow a short estimate entirely.
- Storm-date disputes where two hail events hit the same summer.
Before repairs start
Photograph every slope and elevation, keep a few stones in the freezer or photographed beside a ruler, and save local storm reports. Once the roof is torn off, the evidence is gone.
Using our tools
Check the hail size against your roof type with the hail size & roof impact checker, measure squares with the roof pitch & squares calculator, and see what your deductible means with the hail percentage deductible calculator.
Common questions
The adjuster found only a few hits per slope. Is that the end of it?
Not necessarily. Test-square counts, the shingle’s condition, repairability and matching all matter. A second inspection and a careful look at the policy often change the picture.
Are Class 4 shingles covered for hail?
Covered damage is covered regardless of shingle class, but some policies have cosmetic-damage exclusions or roof endorsements. Read the declarations and endorsements together.
Can I get a new roof if only some slopes are damaged?
It depends on the damage, the policy and whether repairs can be made to match. Appraisal can resolve disputes about the cost to repair or replace the damaged parts.




